It appears you have not yet Signed Up with our community. To Sign Up for free, please click here....



Knee & Hip Problems Message Board


Knee & Hip Problems Board Index


Hi :)

From my limited vantage point, it would seem to me very strange to utilize donor tissue for this repair, so it sounds as if the surgeon does not expect much viable tissue and there's probably not a lot of prior research on how to circumvent that. Columbia Presby is really on the cutting edge in many areas (no pun intended), so there may be zip data outside a very few surgeries, not easily accessible to the public as the results may not even yet be published.

If you want a second opinion, there's a doc in NYC who people are willing to fly out to due to his high expertise in this area and who might provide an informative second opinion. His info is given within the beginning posts of the older thread' started by 'Tomorrow'. I noticed you're a senior member, so I don't know if you've accessed the long thread yet--it does not have any references to the use of donor tissue, but there is a lot of relevant and helpful information. I do think you're going to have to find a solution that doesn't include using stairs for at least a few months, but your surgeon will help you our with those issues.

The following doesn't relate to your question but gives a sense of what I'm learning in dealing with my own problem. I thought of starting another thread, as there are more of us who need to learn ongoing developments on this topic, but I think your post was a good way to re-start one, although the tissue grafting (?) is more specific than most people can address. I'm too new to know how this works.

I just joined tonight and am in the process of finding competent covered, repeat covered, treatment for a gluteal tear. (I felt really bad for the poster who is now uninsured and plan to post privately with some suggestions.) I have no family or real friends where I am living--hard to make friends when you're housebound--but am too compromised to move back to where my friends are, although I may have no choice. I can't even go food shopping without feeling like I'll pass out right now. (I do have two lovely Hungarian Sheepdogs, one--the 110 lb. Komondor--is probably implicated in my bilateral shoulder injuries, as well as the probable gluteal tear. Neither tolerates less than complete subservience to their needs.) In reading of the recovery process from the several treatments that posters have undergone, I'm really getting frightened, but the pain has become really unbearable and relentless.

The MRI of my pre-op L shoulder completely missed the 'significant' chondrolysis and labral tear, in addition to the expected findings, which enchanted (not) my surgeon during an arthroscopic repair. The R shoulder MRI does note the labral tear in addition to the tendon tear, etc., without mention of severe chondrolysis and my doc has this false hope that the surgery in Jan will not be so bad. I had an MRI of my hip on the 14th with several findings, tendinopathy, bursitis, subchondral cyst, and some unidentifiable little bugger. The info provided on the shoulder was simply to indicate that I don't have massive faith in MRIs, as actual op findings seem to be at frequent variance with them, and I think the consensus is that clinical findings are more accurate in diagnosing hip problems. Of course the typical course is to send a patient through a series of different specialists, which is sort of like the three blind men describing an elephant while holding different parts. Humorous if you weren't in such pain and losing your life. Then you add in the insurance requirement for 'evidence' that justifies the expenditure for treatment.... (Having worked in healthcare, the purpose of sending patients through this gauntlet of ineffective therapies is not to follow a systematic path of less invasive treatment, as purported, but to induce the patient to drop out before the really costly alternative of surgery is utilized. It's really not cost-effective, but healthcare executives are not financial wizards, just greedy ones.)

Anyway, I'm here to learn as much as I can from those kind souls who've allowed others to benefit from their difficult journeys in trying to get adequate treatment for gluteal tears. As the previous poster noted, there is a very long thread that has been closed, and which I wish remained open, as there will be plenty more of us trying to find answers on this topic which are not being provided by our 'providers.' Thank you so much to those who did provide information to the rest of us in that thread. I wish I could do the same for the initial poster in this one.





All times are GMT -7. The time now is 12:38 PM.





© 2022 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved.
Do not copy or redistribute in any form!