It appears you have not yet Signed Up with our community. To Sign Up for free, please click here....

Relationship Health Message Board

Relationship Health Board Index

Hi! I'm new here, but I was hoping to get some opinions on my situation. I really appreciate any and all responses, so thanks in advance for your time. I'll be as brief as I can, but my question is somewhat multi-faceted.

First, some important background:
I'm in my late 20s, and I have a good education and job.

Back in college, I met a guy while I was in a long distance relationship with someone else. We had a great friendship. Obviously the LD thing didn't work out, and then I decided to date this guy at college. This guy always made it clear that he wanted to be with me even when we were just friends - and unfortunately, my reluctance to be with him due to my prior LD relationship at the time caused some issues for us when we actually did start dating (surely, he felt like he was the second choice guy for me). But we had a fantastic emotional, intellectual connection. He really understood me, respected and supported my interests and was just generally a caring person. I ended up breaking up with him after a couple of years for some salient issues: he would get jealous of my male friends, he had major insecurities about his own future and would often put his self-worth on me and our relationship, plus I had my own growing to do at the time and felt I would best figure out my path on my own.

Years later, we're both living in the same city - but I'm about to move out of town for a job. We meet a few days before I'm moving just to catch up and say hello. Our wonderful connection hadn't vanished at all, it was like time and distance didn't matter at all. I should add that he overcame a lot of the hurdles he had faced in terms of his professional well-being and more, and really emerged as a better, stronger person. Our lasting connection was very unexpected. But I was moving. So I decided to come down and visit in the ensuing months, to see where things might go. Things were good, but in the end, I realized that in order to make a new life for myself in my new location, I needed to let go and not hold on to the city and the people there. So I never fully pursued it.

Then, at least a half year later, I met someone new in my new town. We started dating - and we're still dating. We've been together for 2.5 years. At first it was wonderful, we were so in love. After a while, I moved into his house (he bought a house before I knew him and has a good job and is very secure in his life; I should mention that I insist on paying "rent" to help with his mortgage and bills, so we still keep our finances separate), things were great. But then I brought up the idea of marriage (after a year of living together) -- and very unexpectedly, he hadn't really thought about it and was unsure about it. Basically, he didn't want to get married yet and when I pressed for a reason, he didn't have one - just that he didn't think that he or we were ready.

This caused me to have some doubts about us -- I really figured that the person I would marry someday would feel the same about me. And I've never been the type of girl to plan my wedding or really seek out marriage -- I really just thought about marriage because I thought he was great. Plus, we were starting to think/make plans for a possible move to a new city, etc., and he didn't think about making any kind of commitment before asking me to move to be with him, which seemed odd. It was out of character for him, especially since he's been pretty forthcoming about the fact that his life goals include marriage and children, etc. Plus, he's in a very stable place, and our relationship was a dream for both of us. Even his mother predicted to him that we would get married, and his good friends adored me - so I know I'm not the only person who felt like the relationship was moving in that direction.

Anyway, I started to pull away because I felt rejected. And things have very slowly and steadily declined between us since.

Then, months later and out of nowhere, I started having dreams about the guy from college who I reconnected with before moving to my current location. And I couldn't get him out of my mind. I just kept thinking that this guy from college really wanted to be with me -- he very openly made it clear to me that he wanted to marry me someday (though, that was in college, which was way to soon for me to think about marriage). Anyway, I had these thoughts that maybe we would have worked out if we had been older, more mature, more stable in our lives. Everything else was always there.

So I ended up breaking up with my current boyfriend months later and went to see this guy, thinking I would try to get him back. But then I started having all these doubts. What if all the problems I used to have with the college boyfriend hadn't actually been resolved with time? Maybe we'd have the same issues all over again. What if I end up missing my current boyfriend once I'm with this old flame? And maybe I was the reason for the decline of what was great relationship, since I pulled away after he wasn't sure about marriage. Maybe I should have had more patience with him about marriage and a future. But maybe not! Maybe the fact that my current boyfriend and I weren't on the same page was a major red flag. Not to mention that my current boyfriend -- while wonderful and supportive, etc. -- really never "got me" the way this other guy did. We just come from such different backgrounds and experiences that he often has a difficult time really understanding me.

Well, I ended up going back to the current boyfriend after about a week. Maybe out of fear, maybe because I wasn't strong enough to leave. Maybe because I hate thinking that I caused the break up with my pulling away and thought that I should at least give it a real shot instead of being distant. Plus, we talked during the time I broke up with him and he said things I wanted to hear: he wanted marriage eventually, and he even finally gave me a reason for his indecision, saying that the reason he didn't want marriage when we talked about it six months ago didn't have anything to do with me. He was just scared of marriage, for some reason. So, OK -- I went back to give it a second chance.

But now I don't want to marry him. Not at all. The idea of marriage makes me cringe now. And we're not in love anymore, like we used to. We're not intimate anymore, we've both pulled away from the relationship. And we've talked about it - and whenever we talk about it, we agree to be more affectionate and to try harder. But nothing really changes.

It may not have changed, in part, because I still think about this other guy. A lot. I keep it to myself, and I'm not in contact with him at all. There's nothing going on there, except some feeling about him that hasn't gone away after all these years.

I think I probably have to break up with my current boyfriend, one way or another. No matter how great the relationship was, we're just not in a good place anymore - and I'm not doing either of us favors by thinking of another person.

But every time I think about the old college boyfriend, I get really scared about that too. I know that there are issues there - I worry he'll always have some insecurities with himself and/or us, and that he may have some jealousy issues still. Maybe no one's perfect and that I can deal with those things to be with someone who really cares about me and understands me (who I understand as well). But maybe they'll just lead to us breaking up again. Things get very serious with us very quickly, from past experience with him, and there always feel like there's a lot at stake. I know if we were to break up again, it would hurt us both very badly. In which case, if there's still a good possibility that we might end up breaking up over time, I might want to think about forgetting about him and really giving my current boyfriend and me a fair shot at something real.

If anyone has any thoughts on this, I would really appreciate it. I feel a bit trapped right now, each possible path has similar and equal risks. Maybe there's a clear path here that I'm just not seeing being so emotionally involved. Thanks!
Thanks everyone for your responses.

I'm in agreement with all of your posts. It definitely makes sense that if I can't choose between these two guys, that neither of them are probably completely right for me.

But I should clear up a couple of misconceptions from justkeeppraying. I have known the old boyfriend for many years, but we really haven't spent any large amount of time together since we broke up back in college - that was 2004, I think. I saw him, in total, for about for or five days combined when we reconnected before/when I moved. And then I saw him for one day during the holidays this past December. It's very difficult to make a decision about someone based on a total of six days together. Those days were all great, but it doesn't really tell me how we're going to be in a long term relationship.

We both have changed, much for the better from my initial impressions. That's another reason why I thought that a relationship now might have a lot of potential. You're right that I don't know if he is still single -- he was when I spoke to him in December/January. But time has passed and it's absolutely possible he has found someone new since then. But on the other hand, I don't think I can stress how strong of a bond we have.

It's the kind of thing where I don't have a lot of doubt that he'd get back together with me, if not immediately, then eventually. Of course I could be wrong, but he has always thought that I was the one for him, even if I've been wishywashy about it. We seem to really understand the way each other thinks. We have very similar backgrounds and family - which was never important to me back in college, but seems to be more important to me the older I get and the more I think about who I want to spend the rest of my life with. We're both really goal oriented people. We don't do the same things, career-wise or even hobby-wise, but our interests kind of come from similar places -- we both love writing, music, arts, etc. We just have different ways of connecting to those things, which is good -- we're not so different that it's difficult to understand each other, but we have enough individuality that we both expand the horizons of the other person.

But I do worry about self-esteem issues that he's had in the past. I worry about the jealousy issues that had been there. I worry that we've had so much back and forth in the past few years that it will be hard for him to get over some of the hurt feelings I've caused him because of it, even if he wants to try.

Another important point worth mentioning might be that I had been on the verge of breaking up with my current boyfriend a couple times before this prior relationship came back into my mind and dreams. It would be easy to say that I'm just using an old flame as a reason to pull away after he didn't want marriage, but I had pulled away sooner. And it wasn't that I had simply considered it but did nothing -- I actually had discussions with my boyfriend about breaking up, telling him I wasn't sure about our relationship since we obviously weren't on the same page about our future. I spend a couple days openly considering it. I didn't end up breaking up with him, but even my boyfriend knows that we've been close to it many times. And when I did break up with him shortly in December, I told him everything - I told him that, in addition to my doubts about us, I had been reconsidering a past relationship that never had closure.

So despite my inability to make a clear decision, I have been very open and honest with all parties about my thoughts. With one exception: Since my boyfriend and I got back together, I haven't mentioned the other guy at all. I haven't told him that I still think about the other guy. I've just been doing my best to try to forget about the other guy, but it's been very difficult to do.

I've mentioned all the good things about my past boyfriend, but there are many great things about my current one. What makes this so difficult is that both guys are really good, kind men who have treated me exceptionally well. My current boyfriend is stable as a rock, which I've always thought was really good for someone like me, who is artsy and creative. While he's surely interested in these things, it's not really what he does at all. He's into science and technology. It can be a good to have such varying interests where you can really learn from each other, but I find it's often hard for us to understand each other. I mean, without being overly specific, what I do for a career sometimes puts him to sleep! That's hard to handle.

Plus, he's not a very social person. I'm not an overly social person either, but I do value my friends, and know the importance of having and cultivating friendships. He has friends from college, but he only sees them a couple times per year. Otherwise, his family is his main form of communication outside our relationship. He definitely has a different kind of relationship with his family than I do with mine. He idolizes his parents and siblings. I've had a very rocky relationship with my family, and my parents are divorced. When I've tried to talk to him a bit about the dynamics of my family, he openly admits that he doesn't really understand it, and that he's not really that comfortable with it. Divorce, in general, is something he's just not comfortable with. So that's another tough thing -- I can't really share with him my life, or vent to him about any issues I'm having with my parents. He just doesn't know how to respond.

But he is very conscientious. He does care about me and makes an effort to go the extra mile for me. We don't argue very much, we're very good about talking through things, even if we don't nearly talk enough about some of our issues.

I find it very difficult to do a side-by-side comparison of these two guys. I don't really care who is better on paper. I just want to be with someone caring and sweet who feels the same big way for me as I do for them.

So maybe neither is the right guy for me. But I would really hate to break up with my current boyfriend and then remember how wonderful he was as soon as I've blown it with him. And I would hate to get back with the other guy, for it to not work out and for us to really hurt each other.

Third option is definitely to break up and not go back to the old guy and just hope something new and better comes along. I definitely don't think that I'll never have another relationship again, or that I'll be alone for the rest of my life. I just, I don't know, I feel like I've really lucked out having great relationships and I just don't understand fully why they can't work out. Maybe I'm just holding on too much and need to let go.

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:55 PM.

© 2020 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved.
Do not copy or redistribute in any form!